best episodes of Evil Lives Here poster

The true stories of people who lived with a killer. How well do you really know your family? Would you recognize the warning signs? Or would you become entangled in evil?

17 Seasons
148 Episodes
Returning Series
Crime Documentary
Cast & Characters
episode image Locked in the Closet
8.9/10 (113 votes)

#1 Locked in the Closet

S11:E1

The first time Alice Jenkins locks Jesse Eging in the closet as a child, he thinks it's only a game. But as Jesse's captivity grows longer and food becomes scarce, he realizes that if he and his siblings do not find a way to escape, they will surely die.

episode image She Made Me Do It
8.3/10 (106 votes)

#2 She Made Me Do It

S2:E2

As a boy, Eric Witte's father taught him to protect his family. But as his father grows increasingly violent, Eric realizes that he is the evil his family needs protection from.

episode image The Face of My Torturer
8.3/10 (87 votes)

#3 The Face of My Torturer

S6:E2

William Knorr's mother, Theresa, always threatened that if she ever went to jail for what she had done, she would take him down with her; after years spent helping her keep the horrors secret, he may go to jail with her.

episode image I Watched Daddy Bury Mommy
8.1/10 (58 votes)

#4 I Watched Daddy Bury Mommy

S13:E1

As a child, Lori Hodge doesn't understand what she sees when her father, Gene Keidel, digs a hole in the yard in the middle of the night, but as she gets older and realizes the truth, she becomes a threat; he will stop at nothing to keep his secret.

episode image I Made It Out Alive
8.1/10 (58 votes)

#5 I Made It Out Alive

S13:E2

For years, every time Gabi Blair walks past the freezer, she shudders at the thought of the horrors hidden inside; forced to keep secret her mother's crimes, she prays that someone will discover the truth before she becomes her mother's next victim.

episode image Son of the Prophet
7.8/10 (77 votes)

#6 Son of the Prophet

S2:E5

Dennis Ryan grew up believing that his father's violent teachings were preparing him to save the lives of everyone in their farmhouse. But by the time Dennis discovers the horrible truth, it is too late-he has already gone too far.

episode image My Secret Nightmare
7.8/10 (80 votes)

#7 My Secret Nightmare

S2:E6

Tiffany Shore grows up knowing her father is evil but keeps his secrets, then she escapes only to be devastated by the discovery that he has committed acts far more heinous than she could have ever imagined.

episode image Put On a Happy Face
7.8/10 (68 votes)

#8 Put On a Happy Face

S3:E11

Melissa Moore loved being “Daddy’s Little Girl” and to her, her father Keith Jesperson, could do no wrong. But as she got older, that admiration was replaced by fear, and then by the horror of learning how close she had come to being his next victim.

episode image My Brother's Secrets
7.7/10 (73 votes)

#9 My Brother's Secrets

S2:E7

Sean Lewis isn't surprised to hear his brother Patrick has been arrested again, but this time around, Sean learns he has been helping a monster lead a secret double life by repeatedly helping his brother get out of jams.

episode image Something Is Different About Robbie
7.6/10 (181 votes)

#10 Something Is Different About Robbie

S1:E1

Though Ronald Hawkins and Candace Sims knew that Robbie was different from an early age, they were unprepared for the violent act that Robbie would commit, a crime that shook the nation.

episode image Not My Boy
7.6/10 (99 votes)

#11 Not My Boy

S2:E1

George and Margaret Keller never suspected that the man terrorizing their city could be a member of their own family. As it dawns on them that their son is hiding a sinister secret, they must decide whether or not to turn him in.

episode image On The Run
7.6/10 (71 votes)

#12 On The Run

S2:E10

Lindsay Wrinkles always knew her father had a short temper, but she never expected to be on the run from him when she was only 14; as she runs from hideout to hideout, desperate to evade him, Wrinkles wonders what will happen if he ever finds her.

episode image What if He Gets Out?
7.6/10 (52 votes)

#13 What if He Gets Out?

S11:E2

When Amy Chessler calls 911 to report what her brother, Jesse Winnick, has confessed to, she doesn't know whether to believe him. Jesse's always been a liar, and Amy doesn't truly understand what he is capable of until she walks in and sees it for herself.

episode image Cheating Death
7.5/10 (104 votes)

#14 Cheating Death

S1:E3

Coming from a broken home, 16-year-old Cathy wanted nothing but love; After meeting Peter Tobin, a man twice her age, she thought she had found the perfect gentleman; After her marriage, Cathy gradually uncovered horrifying secrets about her husband.How would she keep herself and her son alive long enough to escape one of the most evil men in modern history?

episode image My Brother, The Devil
7.5/10 (77 votes)

#15 My Brother, The Devil

S2:E3

Wallace Jeffs was raised to believe that his half-brother, Warren, would guide his family to salvation. But when his nephew reveals Warren's true nature, Wallace will have to choose between loyalty to his family or to his church's new prophet.

episode image The Horror I Don't Remember
7.5/10 (84 votes)

#16 The Horror I Don't Remember

S2:E4

Sherry Shafer never had a good relationship with her younger brother, Brian Britton, but she never expected to lose everything because of him. Today, all she has left is the fear that one day he will return to finish what he started 26 years ago.

episode image Our House of Horrors
7.5/10 (83 votes)

#17 Our House of Horrors

S2:E8

Alice Swafford envies her childhood neighbor William Jennings Choyce for his perfect life, then she marries him and realizes his life wasn't perfect below the surface.

episode image What If He Was Innocent?
7.5/10 (53 votes)

#18 What If He Was Innocent?

S9:E1

Some say Cameron Todd Willingham was wrongfully convicted, and the court put an innocent man to death. But Stacy Kuykendall knew Todd better than anyone, and she's convinced that he was a monster who was guilty as charged and deserved to die.

episode image The Monster I Married
7.4/10 (75 votes)

#19 The Monster I Married

S3:E2

When Cindy first fell in love with Bobby Long, she never imagined that she would one day regret not committing murder. But years after she first discovered the horrifying truth, she is haunted by the night when she decided not to kill him in his sleep.

episode image My Brother Made History
7.4/10 (51 votes)

#20 My Brother Made History

S7:E4

As a boy, Travis Spencer always told himself that the cruel pranks his older brother, Timothy, played on him were ultimately harmless. He never suspected that his brother was using him to practice methods of torture that would be used on others.

episode image I Will Always Be Scared of Him
7.4/10 (40 votes)

#21 I Will Always Be Scared of Him

S11:E3

From the moment Deborah Williamson meets her stepson, David Shafer, she knows there is something unsettling about him, but when her warnings about his frightening behavior go unheeded, the devastation he ultimately wreaks is beyond anything she imagines.

episode image Home Sweet Nightmare
7.3/10 (92 votes)

#22 Home Sweet Nightmare

S1:E6

Sheila Janutolo dreaded being alone with her husband Jim Cruz. Over the years, she had learned to fear him and his violent temper. But when she got a call that he'd been arrested for a ghastly crime, she was certain police had the wrong man.

episode image First Love, Forever Evil
7.3/10 (67 votes)

#23 First Love, Forever Evil

S3:E6

Melissa Holland was certain that her high school boyfriend, Michael Overstreet, was the man she’d always dreamed of. But only after they were married did she begin to realize that her determination to live happily ever after had put her in mortal danger.

episode image They Found Them In Storage
7.3/10 (43 votes)

#24 They Found Them In Storage

S8:E7

When Wilda Gadd married Howard Willis, she dismissed the rumors about him. That is until she found herself wired up and risking her life to find the dismembered bodies of his victims. She discovered that his secret life was darker than any rumor.

episode image He Pretends to Be Human
7.3/10 (42 votes)

#25 He Pretends to Be Human

S9:E4

When Kelly Pletcher heard what her ex-husband Wayne Adam Ford carried in his pocket while surrendering to police, she was horrified and disgusted - but not surprised. The real surprise was that she managed to escape before becoming one of his victims.

episode image My Brother's Secret
7.2/10 (114 votes)

#26 My Brother's Secret

S1:E2

Danyall White tells the gripping true story of her brother Richard. Danyall always thought he was a prankster who told stories. But when his stories started getting more and more violent, she slowly realized that her brother was hiding a monstrous secret.

episode image The Black Widow
7.2/10 (59 votes)

#27 The Black Widow

S3:E4

Teenager Cindy Taylor's world is shattered by the sudden death of her father; while police say he died of a heart attack, Taylor will discover the cause of her father's death is just one of the deadly secrets her mother had been hiding from her.

episode image My Son's Prisoner
7.2/10 (153 votes)

#28 My Son's Prisoner

S3:E5

Shelly Lietz had been afraid of her son ever since he was four years old. She knew she saw something evil in his eyes that scared her. As he got older and more violent, that fear crippled her, eventually making her a prisoner in her own home.

episode image Blood Atonement
7.2/10 (59 votes)

#29 Blood Atonement

S3:E9

Estephania LeBaron was raised to believe that her father and brothers were holy men, and that the terrible things they did in God’s name were just. But she questions everything when faced with having to do the same terrible things herself.

episode image The Demon In His Eyes
7.2/10 (66 votes)

#30 The Demon In His Eyes

S3:E10

As children, Betty and Ulayla adored their little brother, Johnny, and tried to protect him. As they got older, Johnny did strange things, but they never believed he was capable of pure evil until he confessed a horrible secret.

episode image The Nights I Don't Remember
7.2/10 (53 votes)

#31 The Nights I Don't Remember

S7:E3

Joylynn Martinez sometimes wakes up and cannot remember what happened the night before; she thinks she must've had too much to drink, never suspecting that her husband, Robert Howard Bruce, was responsible, and that he was just getting started.

episode image My Son is Damaged Goods
7.2/10 (43 votes)

#32 My Son is Damaged Goods

S9:E2

Jeanne Avsenew and her young son Peter were close, but as Peter matured, his obsession with death grew. The day Jeanne finds a bullet with her name scrawled on it, she realizes her son wants her dead, and Jeanne must take drastic measures to keep safe.

episode image The Soap Star's Secret
7.1/10 (62 votes)

#33 The Soap Star's Secret

S3:E7

Actor Thom Bierdz brings his troubled younger brother, Troy, out to Los Angeles to help set him straight; Thom turns out to be wrong about being able to help his brother and pays with the life of a loved one.

episode image Master Manipulator
7.1/10 (55 votes)

#34 Master Manipulator

S4:E6

When Brian Cargill divorces his wife, Kimberly, he thinks it's the end of the worst time of his life; instead, he finds himself in a desperate battle to save his son, Jamie, from her deadly wrath.

episode image He Was My Hero and a Monster
7.1/10 (41 votes)

#35 He Was My Hero and a Monster

S10:E6

As a child, Daniel Rolle idolizes his father, Donald, until Donald's rage makes everyone suffer. When that eventually leads to murder, Daniel must decide if he still loves his father enough to beg a jury not to kill him.

episode image I Want to Watch His Last Breath
7.1/10 (32 votes)

#36 I Want to Watch His Last Breath

S10:E7

Cathy Mills is only a teenager when her fairytale marriage to Robert Walden turns into a nightmare. Still, it is not until she sees a police sketch of her husband that she realizes only she knows the true identity of the monster authorities are hunting.

episode image The Prophet
7.0/10 (92 votes)

#37 The Prophet

S1:E4

To Kevin Currie, Mormon prophet Jeffrey Lundgren was more than a spiritual leader, he was a brother. But before long, Kevin realized that this Man of God was really a devil in disguise with an evil plan.

episode image Deadly Fetish
7.0/10 (64 votes)

#38 Deadly Fetish

S3:E3

When Debra’s husband Robert Rhoads accused her of being cold and immature for refusing to experiment sexually, she thought something was wrong with her. She never suspected her husband’s perversions were signs that there was something evil deep within him.

episode image He Said There Were More of Them
6.9/10 (58 votes)

#39 He Said There Were More of Them

S7:E10

It never occurred to Shirley Gaskins that the father she adored could be one of the most prolific serial killers in America, but the more people vanished without explanation, the harder it was to deny.

episode image In Love with the Devil
6.8/10 (116 votes)

#40 In Love with the Devil

S1:E5

Bernadette was 17 when her boyfriend, Brian Sugrim, told her he had murdered someone. But she didn't believe him. Only years later would she realize the true evil that Brian was capable of.

Cast & Chracters

The highest rated episode of Evil Lives Here is "Locked in the Closet" (S11E1) with a rating of 8.90.

This episode received 113 votes.


The lowest rated episode is "The Monster Inside Him" (S3E12) with a rating of 6.40.

This episode received 8 votes.

The highest rated episode is "Something Is Different About Robbie" (S1E1) with a rating of 7.60.

This episode received 181 votes.


The lowest rated episode is "In Love with the Devil" (S1E5) with a rating of 6.80.

This episode received 116 votes.

The highest rated episode is "She Made Me Do It" (S2E2) with a rating of 8.30.

This episode received 106 votes.


The lowest rated episode is "Trapped in Hell" (S2E9) with a rating of 6.80.

This episode received 73 votes.

The highest rated episode is "Put On a Happy Face" (S3E11) with a rating of 7.80.

This episode received 68 votes.


The lowest rated episode is "The Monster Inside Him" (S3E12) with a rating of 6.40.

This episode received 8 votes.

The highest rated episode is "Master Manipulator" (S4E6) with a rating of 7.10.

This episode received 55 votes.


The lowest rated episode is "Master Manipulator" (S4E6) with a rating of 7.10.

This episode received 55 votes.

The highest rated episode is "I Hate Being Daddy's Girl" (S5E8) with a rating of 6.80.

This episode received 54 votes.


The lowest rated episode is "I Hate Being Daddy's Girl" (S5E8) with a rating of 6.80.

This episode received 54 votes.

The highest rated episode is "The Face of My Torturer" (S6E2) with a rating of 8.30.

This episode received 87 votes.


The lowest rated episode is "The Face of My Torturer" (S6E2) with a rating of 8.30.

This episode received 87 votes.

The highest rated episode is "My Brother Made History" (S7E4) with a rating of 7.40.

This episode received 51 votes.


The lowest rated episode is "You Have to Get Out" (S7E7) with a rating of 6.80.

This episode received 47 votes.

The highest rated episode is "They Found Them In Storage" (S8E7) with a rating of 7.30.

This episode received 43 votes.


The lowest rated episode is "They Found Them In Storage" (S8E7) with a rating of 7.30.

This episode received 43 votes.

The highest rated episode is "What If He Was Innocent?" (S9E1) with a rating of 7.50.

This episode received 53 votes.


The lowest rated episode is "My Son is Damaged Goods" (S9E2) with a rating of 7.20.

This episode received 43 votes.

The highest rated episode is "He Was My Hero and a Monster" (S10E6) with a rating of 7.10.

This episode received 41 votes.


The lowest rated episode is "He Was My Hero and a Monster" (S10E6) with a rating of 7.10.

This episode received 41 votes.

The highest rated episode is "Locked in the Closet" (S11E1) with a rating of 8.90.

This episode received 113 votes.


The lowest rated episode is "He Was A False Prophet" (S11E5) with a rating of 6.60.

This episode received 44 votes.

The highest rated episode is "I Watched Daddy Bury Mommy" (S13E1) with a rating of 8.10.

This episode received 58 votes.


The lowest rated episode is "The Hole in the Backyard" (S13E8) with a rating of 6.80.

This episode received 38 votes.

Similar Shows You Might Like