best episodes of After Midnight poster

Best Episodes of After Midnight

Discover the highest rated episodes of After Midnight. These episodes represent the highest rated by viewers.

Best 3 Episodes

Click to view all episode ratings

# Episode Season Rating
1 2/8/24 (Billy Eichner, Nico Santos, Pete Holmes) S1:E15 ★ 8.3
2 2/5/24 (Bianca Del Rio, Reggie Watts, Wendi McLendon-Covey) S1:E12 ★ 7.9
3 2/11/24 (Wayne Brady, Maria Bamford, Kevin Smith) S1:E16 ★ 7.9

Celebrated comedian Taylor Tomlinson hosts the smartest show on television about the dumbest things on the internet alongside a panel of guests from the worlds of entertainment, comedy, music and beyond.

2 Seasons
152 Episodes
Returning Series
Comedy Talk
Cast & Characters
episode image 2/8/24 (Billy Eichner, Nico Santos, Pete Holmes)
★ 8.3/10 (38 votes)

#1 2/8/24 (Billy Eichner, Nico Santos, Pete Holmes)

S1:E15

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comics Billy Eichner, Pete Holmes, and actor Nico Santos.

episode image 2/5/24 (Bianca Del Rio, Reggie Watts, Wendi McLendon-Covey)
★ 7.9/10 (33 votes)

#2 2/5/24 (Bianca Del Rio, Reggie Watts, Wendi McLendon-Covey)

S1:E12

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes drag queen Bianca Del Rio, comic Reggie Watts and actress Wendi McLendon-Covey.

episode image 2/11/24 (Wayne Brady, Maria Bamford, Kevin Smith)
★ 7.9/10 (37 votes)

#3 2/11/24 (Wayne Brady, Maria Bamford, Kevin Smith)

S1:E16

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes TV host Wayne Brady, comic Maria Bamford and filmmaker Kevin Smith.

episode image 2/12/24 (Riki Lindhome, Rob Huebel, Vinny Thomas)
★ 7.4/10 (32 votes)

#4 2/12/24 (Riki Lindhome, Rob Huebel, Vinny Thomas)

S1:E17

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes actess Riki Lindhome, actor Rob Huebel and actor Vinny Thomas.

episode image 1/17/24 (Paul F. Tompkins, Sophie Buddle, Carl Tart)
★ 7.2/10 (50 votes)

#5 1/17/24 (Paul F. Tompkins, Sophie Buddle, Carl Tart)

S1:E2

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes Paul F. Tompkins, Sophie Buddle, Carl Tart.

episode image 2/6/24 (Taylor Ortega, Jon Gabrus, Megan Gailey)
★ 7.1/10 (29 votes)

#6 2/6/24 (Taylor Ortega, Jon Gabrus, Megan Gailey)

S1:E13

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comics Taylor Ortega, Jon Gabrus, and Megan Gailey.

episode image 2/7/24 (Dusty Slay, London Hughes, Sarah Tiana)
★ 7.0/10 (29 votes)

#7 2/7/24 (Dusty Slay, London Hughes, Sarah Tiana)

S1:E14

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comics Dusty Slay, London Hughes, and Sarah Tiana.

episode image 1/16/24 (Whitney Cummings, Aparna Narcherla, Kurt Braunohler)
★ 6.5/10 (80 votes)

#8 1/16/24 (Whitney Cummings, Aparna Narcherla, Kurt Braunohler)

S1:E1

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comics Whitney Cummings, Aparna Nancherla, Kurt Braunohler.

episode image 1/18/24 (Max Greenfield, James Davis, Robby Hoffman)
★ 6.3/10 (48 votes)

#9 1/18/24 (Max Greenfield, James Davis, Robby Hoffman)

S1:E3

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comics James Davis, Robby Hoffman and actor Max Greenfield.

episode image 1/22/24 (Chad Daniels, Kelsey Cook, Milana Vayntrub)
★ 0.0/10

#10 1/22/24 (Chad Daniels, Kelsey Cook, Milana Vayntrub)

S1:E4

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes Comic Chad Daniels; comic Kelsey Cook; actress Milana Vayntrub.

episode image 1/23/24 (Atsuko Okatsuka, Josh Johnson, Doug Benson)
★ 0.0/10

#11 1/23/24 (Atsuko Okatsuka, Josh Johnson, Doug Benson)

S1:E5

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comics Atsuko Okatsuka, Josh Johnson and Doug Benson.

episode image 1/24/24 (Guy Branum, Lisa Gilroy, Marcella Arguello)
★ 0.0/10

#12 1/24/24 (Guy Branum, Lisa Gilroy, Marcella Arguello)

S1:E6

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comics Guy Branum, Lisa Gilroy and Marcella Arguello.

episode image 1/25/24 (Natasha Leggero, Moshe Kasher, Jon Daly)
★ 0.0/10

#13 1/25/24 (Natasha Leggero, Moshe Kasher, Jon Daly)

S1:E7

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comics Natasha Leggero, Moshe Kasher and actor Jon Daly.

episode image 1/29/24 (Jerry O'Connell, Arden Myrin, Mary Lynn Rajskub)
★ 0.0/10

#14 1/29/24 (Jerry O'Connell, Arden Myrin, Mary Lynn Rajskub)

S1:E8

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes actor Jerry O'Connell, actress Arden Myrin and actress Mary Lynn Rajskub.

episode image 1/30/24 (Suzi Barrett, Matt Walsh, Vanessa Gonzalez)
★ 0.0/10

#15 1/30/24 (Suzi Barrett, Matt Walsh, Vanessa Gonzalez)

S1:E9

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comics Suzi Barrett, Vanessa Gonzalez and actor Matt Walsh.

episode image 1/31/24 (Sasheer Zamata, Joyelle Nicole Johnson, John Hodgman)
★ 0.0/10

#16 1/31/24 (Sasheer Zamata, Joyelle Nicole Johnson, John Hodgman)

S1:E10

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes actress Sasheer Zamata, comic Joyelle Nicole Johnson and actor John Hodgman.

episode image 2/1/24 (Thomas Lennon, Kel Mitchell, Melissa Villaseñor)
★ 0.0/10

#17 2/1/24 (Thomas Lennon, Kel Mitchell, Melissa Villaseñor)

S1:E11

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes actors Thomas Lennon, Kel Mitchell and comic Melissa Villaseñor.

episode image 2/13/24 (Lauren Lapkus, Ashley Nicole Black, Irene Tu)
★ 0.0/10

#18 2/13/24 (Lauren Lapkus, Ashley Nicole Black, Irene Tu)

S1:E18

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comics Ashley Nicole Black, Irene Tu, and actress Lauren Lapkus.

episode image 2/14/24 (Will Miles, Giulia Rozzi, Brian McElhaney, Nick Kocher, Anna Seregina, Chris Thayer)
★ 0.0/10

#19 2/14/24 (Will Miles, Giulia Rozzi, Brian McElhaney, Nick Kocher, Anna Seregina, Chris Thayer)

S1:E19

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comics Will Miles and Giulia Rozzi, actors Brian McElhaney and Nick Kocher, actress Anna Seregina and comic Chris Thayer.

episode image 2/26/24 (Brendan Hunt, Marc Maron, Zainab Johnson)
★ 0.0/10

#20 2/26/24 (Brendan Hunt, Marc Maron, Zainab Johnson)

S1:E20

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes actor Brendan Hunt, comic Marc Maron and comic Zainab Johnson.

episode image 2/27/24 (Caitlin Peluffo, Dulcé Sloan, Jenny Zigrino)
★ 0.0/10

#21 2/27/24 (Caitlin Peluffo, Dulcé Sloan, Jenny Zigrino)

S1:E21

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes actress Caitlin Peluffo, comic Dulcé Sloan and comic Jenny Zigrino.

episode image 2/28/24 (Fortune Feimster, Mae Martin, Tig Notaro)
★ 0.0/10

#22 2/28/24 (Fortune Feimster, Mae Martin, Tig Notaro)

S1:E22

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comic Fortune Feimster, comic Mae Martin and comic Tig Notaro.

episode image 2/29/24 (W. Kamau Bell, Nish Kumar, Anjelah Johnson-Reyes)
★ 0.0/10

#23 2/29/24 (W. Kamau Bell, Nish Kumar, Anjelah Johnson-Reyes)

S1:E23

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comic W. Kamau Bell, comic Nish Kumar and actress Anjelah Johnson-Reyes.

episode image 3/4/24 (Rob Riggle, Adam Ray, Monét X Change)
★ 0.0/10

#24 3/4/24 (Rob Riggle, Adam Ray, Monét X Change)

S1:E24

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes actor Rob Riggle, comic Adam Ray and drag queen Monét X Change.

episode image 3/5/24 (Esther Povitsky, Haley Joel Osment, Kurt Braunohler)
★ 0.0/10

#25 3/5/24 (Esther Povitsky, Haley Joel Osment, Kurt Braunohler)

S1:E25

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes actress Esther Povitsky, actor Haley Joel Osment and comic Kurt Braunohler.

episode image 9/3/24 (Thomas Lennon, Kimia Behpoornia, Sandy Honig)
★ 0.0/10

#26 9/3/24 (Thomas Lennon, Kimia Behpoornia, Sandy Honig)

S2:E1

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes actor Thomas Lennon, actress Kimia Behpoornia and film producer Sandy Honig.

episode image 9/4/24 (Guy Branum, Kate Micucci, James Davis)
★ 0.0/10

#27 9/4/24 (Guy Branum, Kate Micucci, James Davis)

S2:E2

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comic Guy Branum, comic Kate Micucci. comic James Davis.

episode image 9/5/24 (Jordan Temple, Will Miles, Suzi Barrett)
★ 0.0/10

#28 9/5/24 (Jordan Temple, Will Miles, Suzi Barrett)

S2:E3

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comic Jordan Temple, actor Will Miles and actress Suzi Barrett.

episode image 9/9/24 (Skylar Astin, Wayne Brady, Mary Holland)
★ 0.0/10

#29 9/9/24 (Skylar Astin, Wayne Brady, Mary Holland)

S2:E4

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes actor Skylar Astin, comic Wayne Brady and comic Mary Holland.

episode image 9/10/24 (Bob the Drag Queen, Caitlin Reilly, Rickey Thompson)
★ 0.0/10

#30 9/10/24 (Bob the Drag Queen, Caitlin Reilly, Rickey Thompson)

S2:E5

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes Bob the Drag Queen, actress Caitlin Reilly and comic Rickey Thompson.

episode image 9/11/24 (Aparna Nancherla, Jon Lovett, Zac Oyama)
★ 0.0/10

#31 9/11/24 (Aparna Nancherla, Jon Lovett, Zac Oyama)

S2:E6

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comic Aparna Nancherla, comic Jon Lovett and actor Zac Oyama.

episode image 9/12/24 (Kurt Braunohler, Tien Tran, Megan Gailey)
★ 0.0/10

#32 9/12/24 (Kurt Braunohler, Tien Tran, Megan Gailey)

S2:E7

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comic Kurt Braunohler, comic Tien Tran and comic Megan Gailey.

episode image 9/16/24 (Paul Feig, Ayden Mayeri, Taylor Ortega)
★ 0.0/10

#33 9/16/24 (Paul Feig, Ayden Mayeri, Taylor Ortega)

S2:E8

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes director Paul Feig, actress Ayden Mayeri and comic Taylor Ortega.

episode image 9/17/24 (Atsuko Okatsuka, Dylan Adler, Reggie Watts)
★ 0.0/10

#34 9/17/24 (Atsuko Okatsuka, Dylan Adler, Reggie Watts)

S2:E9

Taylor Tomlinson comic Atsuko Okatsuka, comic Dylan Adler and comic Reggie Watts.

episode image 9/18/24 (Taran Killam, Jay Pharoah, Mary Lynn Rajskub)
★ 0.0/10

#35 9/18/24 (Taran Killam, Jay Pharoah, Mary Lynn Rajskub)

S2:E10

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes actor Taran Killam, comic Jay Pharoah and actress Mary Lynn Rajskub.

episode image 9/19/24 (Lake Bell, James Adomian, Opey Olagbaju)
★ 0.0/10

#36 9/19/24 (Lake Bell, James Adomian, Opey Olagbaju)

S2:E11

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes actress Lake Bell, comic James Adomian and comic Opey Olagbaju.

episode image 9/23/24 (Lauren Lapkus, Paul F. Tompkins, Rachel Pegram)
★ 0.0/10

#37 9/23/24 (Lauren Lapkus, Paul F. Tompkins, Rachel Pegram)

S2:E12

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes actress Lauren Lapkus, comic Paul F. Tompkins and comic Rachel Pegram.

episode image 9/24/24 (Affion Crockett, Jade Catta-Preta, Laura Peek)
★ 0.0/10

#38 9/24/24 (Affion Crockett, Jade Catta-Preta, Laura Peek)

S2:E13

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comic Affion Crockett, film producer Jade Catta-Preta and comic Laura Peek.

episode image 9/25/24 (Jess McKenna, Pete Holmes, Echo Kellum)
★ 0.0/10

#39 9/25/24 (Jess McKenna, Pete Holmes, Echo Kellum)

S2:E14

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comic Jess McKenna, comic Pete Holmes and comic Echo Kellum.

episode image 9/26/24 (Raanan Hershberg, Sarah Tiana, Orlando Leyba)
★ 0.0/10

#40 9/26/24 (Raanan Hershberg, Sarah Tiana, Orlando Leyba)

S2:E15

Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comic Raanan Hershberg, comic Sarah Tiana and comic Orlando Leyba.

Cast & Chracters

character image Self - Host

Self - Host

Actor: Taylor Tomlinson

The highest rated episode of After Midnight is "2/8/24 (Billy Eichner, Nico Santos, Pete Holmes)" (S1E15) with a rating of 8.30.

This episode received 38 votes.

The lowest rated episode is "1/18/24 (Max Greenfield, James Davis, Robby Hoffman)" (S1E3) with a rating of 6.30.

This episode received 48 votes.

The highest rated episode is "2/8/24 (Billy Eichner, Nico Santos, Pete Holmes)" (S1E15) with a rating of 8.30.

This episode received 38 votes.

The lowest rated episode is "1/18/24 (Max Greenfield, James Davis, Robby Hoffman)" (S1E3) with a rating of 6.30.

This episode received 48 votes.

Name Department Job
Carrie Byalick Production Executive Producer
Eric Pierce Production Executive Producer
Evelyn McGee-Colbert Production Executive Producer
Henry R. Muñoz III Production Executive Producer
Jack Martin Production Executive Producer
James Dixon Production Executive Producer
Jason U. Nadler Production Executive Producer
Joe Farrell Production Executive Producer
Mike Farah Production Executive Producer
Stephen Colbert Production Executive Producer
Tom Purcell Production Executive Producer
Whitney Hodack Production Executive Producer

Similar Shows You Might Like

similar show Everybody's Live with John Mulaney
similar show Jimbo Presents: It's My Special Show!